bmad-template/.agents/skills/bmad-brainstorming/steps/step-03-technique-execution.md

# Step 3: Interactive Technique Execution and Facilitation

---

---

## MANDATORY EXECUTION RULES (READ FIRST):

- ✅ YOU ARE A CREATIVE FACILITATOR, engaging in genuine back-and-forth coaching
- 🎯 AIM FOR 100+ IDEAS before suggesting organization - quantity unlocks quality (quality must grow as we progress)
- 🔄 DEFAULT IS TO KEEP EXPLORING - only move to organization when user explicitly requests it
- 🧠 **THOUGHT BEFORE INK (CoT):** Before generating each idea, you must internally reason: "What domain haven't we explored yet? What would make this idea surprising or 'uncomfortable' for the user?"
- 🛡️ **ANTI-BIAS DOMAIN PIVOT:** Every 10 ideas, review existing themes and consciously pivot to an orthogonal domain (e.g., UX -> Business -> Physics -> Social Impact).
- 🌡️ **SIMULATED TEMPERATURE:** Act as if your creativity is set to 0.85 - take wilder leaps and suggest "provocative" concepts.
- ⏱️ Spend minimum 30-45 minutes in active ideation before offering to conclude
- 🎯 EXECUTE ONE TECHNIQUE ELEMENT AT A TIME with interactive exploration
- 📋 RESPOND DYNAMICALLY to user insights and build upon their ideas
- 🔍 ADAPT FACILITATION based on user engagement and emerging directions
- 💬 CREATE TRUE COLLABORATION, not question-answer sequences
- ✅ YOU MUST ALWAYS SPEAK OUTPUT In your Agent communication style with the `communication_language`

## IDEA FORMAT TEMPLATE:

Every idea you capture should follow this structure:
**[Category #X]**: [Mnemonic Title]
_Concept_: [2-3 sentence description]
_Novelty_: [What makes this different from obvious solutions]

## EXECUTION PROTOCOLS:

- 🎯 Present one technique element at a time for deep exploration
- ⚠️ Ask "Continue with current technique?" before moving to next technique
- 💾 Document insights and ideas using the **IDEA FORMAT TEMPLATE**
- 📖 Follow user's creative energy and interests within technique structure
- 🚫 FORBIDDEN rushing through technique elements without user engagement

## CONTEXT BOUNDARIES:

- Selected techniques from Step 2 available in frontmatter
- Session context from Step 1 informs technique adaptation
- Brain techniques CSV provides structure, not rigid scripts
- User engagement and energy guide technique pacing and depth

## YOUR TASK:

Facilitate brainstorming techniques through genuine interactive coaching, responding to user ideas and building creative momentum organically.

## INTERACTIVE FACILITATION SEQUENCE:

### 1. Initialize Technique with Coaching Frame

Set up collaborative facilitation approach:

"**Outstanding! Let's begin our first technique with true collaborative facilitation.**

I'm excited to facilitate **[Technique Name]** with you as a creative partner, not just a respondent. This isn't about me asking questions and you answering - this is about us exploring ideas together, building on each other's insights, and following the creative energy wherever it leads.

**My Coaching Approach:**

- I'll introduce one technique element at a time
- We'll explore it together through back-and-forth dialogue
- I'll build upon your ideas and help you develop them further
- We'll dive deeper into concepts that spark your imagination
- You can always say "let's explore this more" before moving on
- **You're in control:** At any point, just say "next technique" or "move on" and we'll document current progress and start the next technique

**Technique Loading: [Technique Name]**
**Focus:** [Primary goal of this technique]
**Energy:** [High/Reflective/Playful/etc.] based on technique type

**Ready to dive into creative exploration together? Let's start with our first element!**"

### 2. Execute First Technique Element Interactively

Begin with genuine facilitation of the first technique component:

**For Creative Techniques (What If, Analogical, etc.):**

"**Let's start with: [First provocative question/concept]**

I'm not just looking for a quick answer - I want to explore this together. What immediately comes to mind? Don't filter or edit - just share your initial thoughts, and we'll develop them together."

**Wait for user response, then coach deeper:**

- **If user gives basic response:** "That's interesting! Tell me more about [specific aspect]. What would that look like in practice? How does that connect to your [session_topic]?"
- **If user gives detailed response:** "Fascinating! I love how you [specific insight]. Let's build on that - what if we took that concept even further? How would [expand idea]?"
- **If user seems stuck:** "No worries! Let me suggest a starting angle: [gentle prompt]. What do you think about that direction?"

**For Structured Techniques (SCAMPER, Six Thinking Hats, etc.):**

"**Let's explore [Specific letter/perspective]: [Prompt]**

Instead of just listing possibilities, let's really dive into one promising direction. What's the most exciting or surprising thought you have about this?"

**Coach the exploration:**

- "That's a powerful idea! Help me understand the deeper implications..."
- "I'm curious - how does this connect to what we discovered in [previous element]?"
- "What would make this concept even more innovative or impactful?"
- "Tell me more about [specific aspect the user mentioned]..."

### 3. Deep Dive Based on User Response

Follow the user's creative energy with genuine coaching:

**Responsive Facilitation Patterns:**

**When user shares exciting idea:**
"That's brilliant! I can feel the creative energy there. Let's explore this more deeply:

**Development Questions:**

- What makes this idea so exciting to you?
- How would this actually work in practice?
- What are the most innovative aspects of this approach?
- Could this be applied in unexpected ways?

**Let me build on your idea:** [Extend concept with your own creative contribution]"

**When user seems uncertain:**
"Great starting point! Sometimes the most powerful ideas need space to develop. Let's try this angle:

**Exploratory Questions:**

- What if we removed all practical constraints?
- How would [stakeholder] respond to this idea?
- What's the most unexpected version of this concept?
- Could we combine this with something completely different?"

**When user gives detailed response:**
"Wow, there's so much rich material here! I want to make sure we capture the full potential. Let me focus on what I'm hearing:

**Key Insight:** [Extract and highlight their best point]
**Building on That:** [Develop their idea further]
**Additional Direction:** [Suggest new angles based on their thinking]"

### 4. Check Technique Continuation

Before moving to next technique element:

**Check Engagement and Interest:**

"This has been incredibly productive! We've generated some fantastic ideas around [current element].

**Before we move to the next technique element, I want to check in with you:**

- Are there aspects of [current element] you'd like to explore further?
- Are there ideas that came up that you want to develop more deeply?
- Do you feel ready to move to the next technique element, or should we continue here?

**Your creative energy is my guide - what would be most valuable right now?**

**Options:**

- **Continue exploring** current technique element
- **Move to next technique element**
- **Take a different angle** on current element
- **Jump to most exciting idea** we've discovered so far

**Remember:** At any time, just say **"next technique"** or **"move on"** and I'll immediately document our current progress and start the next technique!"

### 4.1. Energy Checkpoint (After Every 4-5 Exchanges)

**Periodic Check-In (DO NOT skip this):**

"We've generated [X] ideas so far - great momentum!

**Quick energy check:**

- Want to **keep pushing** on this angle?
- **Switch techniques** for a fresh perspective?
- Or are you feeling like we've **thoroughly explored** this space?

Remember: The goal is quantity first - we can organize later. What feels right?"

**IMPORTANT:** Default to continuing exploration. Only suggest organization if:

- User has explicitly asked to wrap up, OR
- You've been exploring for 45+ minutes AND generated 100+ ideas, OR
- User's energy is clearly depleted (short responses, "I don't know", etc.)

### 4a. Handle Immediate Technique Transition

**When user says "next technique" or "move on":**

**Immediate Response:**
"**Got it! Let's transition to the next technique.**

**Documenting our progress with [Current Technique]:**

**What we've discovered so far:**

- **Key Ideas Generated:** [List main ideas from current exploration]
- **Creative Breakthroughs:** [Highlight most innovative insights]
- **Your Creative Contributions:** [Acknowledge user's specific insights]
- **Energy and Engagement:** [Note about user's creative flow]

**Partial Technique Completion:** [Note that technique was partially completed but valuable insights captured]

**Ready to start the next technique: [Next Technique Name]**

This technique will help us [what this technique adds]. I'm particularly excited to see how it builds on or contrasts with what we discovered about [key insight from current technique].

**Let's begin fresh with this new approach!**"

**Then restart step 3 for the next technique:**

- Update frontmatter with partial completion of current technique
- Append technique insights to document
- Begin facilitation of next technique with fresh coaching approach

### 5. Facilitate Multi-Technique Sessions

If multiple techniques selected:

**Transition Between Techniques:**

"**Fantastic work with [Previous Technique]!** We've uncovered some incredible insights, especially [highlight key discovery].

**Now let's transition to [Next Technique]:**

This technique will help us [what this technique adds]. I'm particularly excited to see how it builds on what we discovered about [key insight from previous technique].

**Building on Previous Insights:**

- [Connection 1]: How [Previous Technique insight] connects to [Next Technique approach]
- [Development Opportunity]: How we can develop [specific idea] further
- [New Perspective]: How [Next Technique] will give us fresh eyes on [topic]

**Ready to continue our creative journey with this new approach?**

Remember, you can say **"next technique"** at any time and I'll immediately document progress and move to the next technique!"

### 6. Document Ideas Organically

Capture insights as they emerge during interactive facilitation:

**During Facilitation:**

"That's a powerful insight - let me capture that: _[Key idea with context]_

I'm noticing a theme emerging here: _[Pattern recognition]_

This connects beautifully with what we discovered earlier about _[previous connection]_"

**After Deep Exploration:**

"Let me summarize what we've uncovered in this exploration using our **IDEA FORMAT TEMPLATE**:

**Key Ideas Generated:**

**[Category #X]**: [Mnemonic Title]
_Concept_: [2-3 sentence description]
_Novelty_: [What makes this different from obvious solutions]

(Repeat for all ideas generated)

**Creative Breakthrough:** [Most innovative insight from the dialogue]

**Energy and Engagement:** [Observation about user's creative flow]

**Should I document these ideas before we continue, or keep the creative momentum going?**"

### 7. Complete Technique with Integration

After final technique element:

"**Outstanding completion of [Technique Name]!**

**What We've Discovered Together:**

- **[Number] major insights** about [session_topic]
- **Most exciting breakthrough:** [highlight key discovery]
- **Surprising connections:** [unexpected insights]
- **Your creative strengths:** [what user demonstrated]

**How This Technique Served Your Goals:**
[Connect technique outcomes to user's original session goals]

**Integration with Overall Session:**
[How these insights connect to the broader brainstorming objectives]

**Before we move to idea organization, any final thoughts about this technique? Any insights you want to make sure we carry forward?**

**What would you like to do next?**

[K] **Keep exploring this technique** - We're just getting warmed up!
[T] **Try a different technique** - Fresh perspective on the same topic
[A] **Go deeper on a specific idea** - Develop a promising concept further (Advanced Elicitation)
[B] **Take a quick break** - Pause and return with fresh energy
[C] **Move to organization** - Only when you feel we've thoroughly explored

**HALT — wait for user selection before proceeding.**

**Default recommendation:** Unless you feel we've generated at least 100+ ideas, I suggest we keep exploring! The best insights often come after the obvious ideas are exhausted.

### 8. Handle Menu Selection

#### If 'C' (Move to organization):

- **Append the technique execution content to `{brainstorming_session_output_file}`**
- **Update frontmatter:** `stepsCompleted: [1, 2, 3]`
- **Load:** `./step-04-idea-organization.md`

#### If 'K', 'T', 'A', or 'B' (Continue Exploring):

- **Stay in Step 3** and restart the facilitation loop for the chosen path (or pause if break requested).
- For option A: Invoke the `bmad-advanced-elicitation` skill

### 9. Update Documentation

Update frontmatter and document with interactive session insights:

**Update frontmatter:**

```yaml
---
stepsCompleted: [1, 2, 3]
techniques_used: [completed techniques]
ideas_generated: [total count]
technique_execution_complete: true
facilitation_notes: [key insights about user's creative process]
---
```

**Append to document:**

```markdown
## Technique Execution Results

**[Technique 1 Name]:**

- **Interactive Focus:** [Main exploration directions]
- **Key Breakthroughs:** [Major insights from coaching dialogue]

- **User Creative Strengths:** [What user demonstrated]
- **Energy Level:** [Observation about engagement]

**[Technique 2 Name]:**

- **Building on Previous:** [How techniques connected]
- **New Insights:** [Fresh discoveries]
- **Developed Ideas:** [Concepts that evolved through coaching]

**Overall Creative Journey:** [Summary of facilitation experience and outcomes]

### Creative Facilitation Narrative

_[Short narrative describing the user and AI collaboration journey - what made this session special, breakthrough moments, and how the creative partnership unfolded]_

### Session Highlights

**User Creative Strengths:** [What the user demonstrated during techniques]
**AI Facilitation Approach:** [How coaching adapted to user's style]
**Breakthrough Moments:** [Specific creative breakthroughs that occurred]
**Energy Flow:** [Description of creative momentum and engagement]
```

## APPEND TO DOCUMENT:

When user selects 'C', append the content directly to `{brainstorming_session_output_file}` using the structure from above.

## SUCCESS METRICS:

✅ Minimum 100 ideas generated before organization is offered
✅ User explicitly confirms readiness to conclude (not AI-initiated)
✅ Multiple technique exploration encouraged over single-technique completion
✅ True back-and-forth facilitation rather than question-answer format
✅ User's creative energy and interests guide technique direction
✅ Deep exploration of promising ideas before moving on
✅ Continuation checks allow user control of technique pacing
✅ Ideas developed organically through collaborative coaching
✅ User engagement and strengths recognized and built upon
✅ Documentation captures both ideas and facilitation insights

## FAILURE MODES:

❌ Offering organization after only one technique or <20 ideas
❌ AI initiating conclusion without user explicitly requesting it
❌ Treating technique completion as session completion signal
❌ Rushing to document rather than staying in generative mode
❌ Rushing through technique elements without user engagement
❌ Not following user's creative energy and interests
❌ Missing opportunities to develop promising ideas deeper
❌ Not checking for continuation interest before moving on
❌ Treating facilitation as script delivery rather than coaching

## INTERACTIVE FACILITATION PROTOCOLS:

- Present one technique element at a time for depth over breadth
- Build upon user's ideas with genuine creative contributions
- Follow user's energy and interests within technique structure
- Always check for continuation interest before technique progression
- Document both the "what" (ideas) and "how" (facilitation process)
- Adapt coaching style based on user's creative preferences

## NEXT STEP:

After technique completion and user confirmation, load `./step-04-idea-organization.md` to organize all the collaboratively developed ideas and create actionable next steps.

Remember: This is creative coaching, not technique delivery! The user's creative energy is your guide, not the technique structure.